read time: 8 minutes

Hey there, {first_name/Resilient Warrior}!

Welcome to this week’s edition of The Saturday Sit Down! Today, we're diving into the fascinating topic of judgment and decision-making. We often hear the advice to "trust your gut," but is that really the best approach? Let's explore why good judgment isn't just about gut feelings—it's about testing those instincts with logic and evidence.

Good Judgment Isn't About Trusting Your Gut. It's About Testing Your Gut.

Today we uncover why relying solely on gut feelings can lead to flawed decisions. Learn how to balance intuition with critical thinking to make better choices in your personal and professional life.

We all have those moments where a gut feeling seems to guide us. But while intuition can be a helpful signal, it shouldn't be the sole basis for our decisions. Here’s why testing your gut instincts is crucial:

1. Bias Awareness: Our guts can be influenced by biases and emotions. By questioning our instincts, we become more aware of these biases and can make more objective decisions.

   Example: Imagine you’re hiring a new team member. Your gut might favor a candidate because they remind you of a successful colleague. However, this bias could overlook a more qualified applicant. Testing your gut by reviewing each candidate’s qualifications objectively ensures a fairer decision.

2. Evidence-Based Decision Making: Testing your gut means seeking out data and evidence to support or challenge your initial feelings. This approach leads to more informed and reliable outcomes.

   Example: You have a gut feeling that a new marketing strategy will be successful. Before implementing it, you gather data from market research and analyze past campaign performances. This evidence either confirms or adjusts your strategy, leading to a more data-driven approach.

3. Balancing Logic and Intuition: Good judgment involves a blend of both intuition and analytical thinking. Learn to recognize when your gut is onto something and when it needs a reality check.

   Example: As a project manager, your gut might tell you a project timeline is too tight. Instead of dismissing this feeling, you analyze project requirements, resources, and past performance data. Combining this analysis with your intuition helps you create a realistic timeline.

4. Scenario Analysis: Consider different scenarios and outcomes to test your gut feelings. This helps in understanding the potential risks and rewards associated with your decision.

   Example: You’re considering a new business venture. Instead of jumping in based on a gut feeling, you conduct a SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) to explore various scenarios. This comprehensive view ensures you’re prepared for different outcomes.

5. Feedback and Reflection: Regularly seek feedback on your decisions and reflect on their outcomes. This practice helps refine your gut instincts over time.

   Example: After completing a project, gather feedback from your team about what went well and what could be improved. Reflecting on this feedback helps you fine-tune your instincts for future projects.

While our guts can provide valuable signals, it’s essential to test these instincts with evidence and critical thinking. By combining intuition with logical analysis, you can make more informed and effective decisions in every aspect of your life.

Quick Favor:

If you found this topic insightful, be sure to read our latest Medium articles on The Benefits of Outdoor Activities for Mental Health. Don’t forget to subscribe to our Medium publication “The Resilient Mindset” for more practical wisdom and friendly conversations.

How to Test your Gut Instincts Effectively

Don’t let your gut lead you astray. Here are practical steps to ensure your decisions are well-rounded and sound.

1. Pause and Reflect: Before acting on a gut feeling, take a moment to reflect. Ask yourself why you feel this way and if there are any underlying biases.

2. Seek Evidence: Look for data or experiences that either support or contradict your gut instinct. This can include research, expert opinions, or past outcomes.

3. Consult Others: Get a second opinion. Sometimes an external perspective can provide clarity and uncover blind spots in your thinking.

4. Evaluate the Risks: Consider the potential risks and benefits of following your gut. Weigh them against the evidence you've gathered.

5. Make a Balanced Decision: Combine your intuition with the evidence and logical analysis to make a well-rounded decision.

📰 Last Week with Scott

Some more writings from the week, if you’re interested check them out.

• The Role of Leadership in Building Resilient Teams

• The Importance of Weekly Reflection and How to Do It Effectively

• Simple Living: Finding Peace in Nature

Most Read This Week:

Personal Update:

What You Learned Today:

• Trust vs. Test: Good judgment involves testing your gut instincts with logic and evidence, not just blindly trusting them.

• Bias Awareness: Recognize and address biases that may influence your gut feelings.

• Evidence-Based Decisions: Seek data and feedback to support or challenge your instincts, ensuring more informed decisions.

• Pause and Reflect: Take a moment to consider why you have a particular gut feeling and whether it is justified.

• Consult Others: Get a second opinion to uncover any blind spots in your thinking and validate your instincts.

• Evaluate Risks and Benefits: Weigh the potential risks and benefits, integrating both intuitive and analytical approaches for balanced decision-making.

By incorporating these strategies, you can enhance your judgment and make better decisions.

Thanks for tuning in to this week’s edition of The Saturday Sit Down. Keep working on your leadership and resilience skills, and remember that every challenge is an opportunity for growth. Until next week!

Warm regards, Scott

Follow me on X: https://x.com/scotthughes691

Subscribe to me on Medium: https://medium.com/@shughes691